Despite the multi-billion dollar market valuations, questions about the commercial value of social media, especially as a business to business marketing channel, continue to be raised – how do you make money out of social media? When the man who runs the world’s largest advertising agency joins the debate, it’s hard to ignore his comments. Sir Martin Sorrell, The chief executive of advertising giant WPP speaking at the Royal Television Society’s Cambridge Convention, questioned if Facebook, Twitter and other social networks can make profits from advertising because, whilst they may have billions of users, will those users accept promotional activity?
“I’m not sceptical about social media,” said Sorrell, “I’m concerned about when you monetise it because by its nature it’s me talking to you electronically, digitally. If I’m talking to you and I send you a commercial message how do you feel about that? If I say ‘buy this’ or ‘do that’, it’s not the right context for sending commercial messages.” However, he also said that social networks were an “extremely powerful way of building brands, building trust and building reputation” because people recommend products to each other.
Consumer advertising is increasingly directing us to Facebook pages or Twitter feeds rather than a business’s URL, but even that somehow feels slightly uncomfortable. I might want to engage with a brand for any number of reasons, but do I really want to befriend it? I certainly wouldn’t want to ram it down the throats of my friends or contacts directly even if I might rave about an especially good, or bad, experience. It’s a bit like being invited to a house party only to find out it’s a pretext to sell you tupperware or candles.
“We used to write letters to each other and now we correspond through Facebook and Twitter and other forms of communication.” Comments Sorrell “If you interrupt that with a message you may run into trouble. Mark Zuckerberg tried two failed experiments — Beacon and one other — which were withdrawn in 24 hours after a revolution on Facebook.” He continued, amid reports that Facebook has been forced to delay its flotation by at least a year because it had missed its revenue target by $400 million.“I have some fundamental doubts about the ability to monetise social platforms,” he said.
Even some of the commercially driven social media enterprises are facing serious questions. Groupon, which promotes local business by offering discount coupons to signed-up subscribers based on location, was last year’s fastest growing company ever according to Forbes magazine and is expected to float for £19 Billion. However, they’re experiencing a
backlash from their business subscribers who have lost money through the scheme having been coerced into offering unsustainable discounts. The discounts have been taken up by ‘professional bargain hunters’ who just follow the deals around rather than becoming customers. Groupon’s new business sign ups are dwindling and many disgruntled partners have left the scheme prompting some analysts to question whether Groupon is just a flash in the pan; “Running a Groupon deal can be a terrible financial decision for merchants. Groupon’s financials also raise questions about its ongoing viability.”










